As a self-proclaimed anime fan, it is sometimes hard to step back from something and really think about it. Aiming for some form of objectivity in reviews, which is never overly objective, compared with simply letting out my inner fan-girl and letting her scream “I love you anime” at the top of her lungs. Anyone who might know me in real life might scoff at the thought of me doing that, but I swear that inner fan-girl exists and sometimes she’s a real pain as she buzzes through my brain like a bee on a sugar high.
Small spoiler warning for The Ancient Magus’ Bride final episode in the images.
And even then, some of you who have simply read my reviews will think, “Hang on a minute, weren’t you the one who gave such-and-such a scathing review or criticised so-and-so for some plot development?” And the answer would definitely be, yes. Because while that inner fan-girl exists and I sometimes love her exuberance, energy and optimism, the reality is that in any particular season of anime there are only so many good shows.
Once you eliminate all of the ones that are outside of your genre or personal preference, sometimes you are lucky to find one or two fairly solid shows within a single season. That doesn’t mean they are the only ones I like. Fan-girl me is happily laughing still at King’s Game and taking somewhat overly excited pleasure in how far Spiritpact has come since its abysmal first episode. If I only found one or two shows I liked, I’d hardly call myself a fan.
But inner fan-girl isn’t alone bouncing around inside my brain. She’s sharing the stage with a lot of different views and one of those is the cynic inside me who waits eagerly to pounce on anything fun and find the flaw (it doesn’t help that some of those flaws are even apparent to the fan-girl). This is the me that waits for things that are rising to fall, and was somewhat smugly satisfied with how KADO ended if only because it meant that inner fan-girl had to take a time out having been bitterly disappointed.
Naturally I am speaking metaphorically and hopefully I don’t actually have multiple personalities streaming around my head for real (it’s crowded enough).
However, this post is about the ‘near great’ in anime and what I want to look at are two shows that have aired either entirely or partially during the Winter 2018 season that both stopped short of reaching greatness (despite the inner fan-girl willing them to be truly amazing). I enjoyed both in different ways and inner fan-girl was incredibly happy watching them. She waited eagerly for the episode to start and basked in the characters and the plot. For one of those shows she also basked in the gorgeous visuals while in the other she tolerated the odd lighting choices but found other things to enjoy. And yet, as the season comes to an end, and I start thinking about recommendations and what to say about these shows, the cynic in me strikes.
So why aren’t they great?
I suppose you could ask that question of almost anything with just as much honest expectation of gaining an answer. “Why aren’t you better?” “Why don’t you match my ideals of what you should be?” “How could you fail there?”
For me though each show has one particular issue that is a sticking point that I cannot overlook. While everything will have its flaws, these are genuine concerns that, regardless of how great some aspects of the shows might be, they will never end up on my list of all time favourites even though they will end up on my list for favourite of the season.
The Ancient Magus’ Bride
If you have followed Weekend Otaku and my collaboration series ‘200 Word Anime‘ you will know that for awhile now I’ve had some misgivings about The Ancient Magus Bride. Mostly petty nit-pickings of a show that is gorgeous to watch, has some excellent music, beautifully depicted magic and folk-lore and a reasonably compelling central couple. Okay, pacing is an issue and the whole cliff-hanger ending without really using it well in the next episode are things that have been minor irritations, but ultimately they aren’t deal breakers with this show and really come down to my own personal tastes.
No, what seals The Ancient Magus’ Bride in my mind as a show that isn’t going to achieve greatness no matter how much I wished it would is how the support cast are ultimately dealt with. That is to say, how they are not dealt with. In the race to bring events to their conclusion, characters are either entirely forgotten or become largely inconsequential. While the main couple get a worthy resolution, other characters still don’t even have a genuine purpose that has been explained. And one of those is a fairly important antagonist during the final episode and I literally have no idea what he actually wants from the confrontation.
Any minor flaws I was over looking or putting down to taste paled in comparison with an ending that tripped over itself to get the main characters to their moment. Realistically, the show needed to move faster earlier on or needed to cull some of the characters when it adapted itself from manga to anime (assigning certain events to different characters to make it work). However, then purists would have accused it of butchering the source material and so this was a no-win situation. Ultimately people are still comparing the anime unfavourably against its source and people who never read the source just found the end a little bemusing even as it maintained the gorgeous quality we had come to expect from the series.
Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens
As we move on, I will note this is not an exceptional show by any means. Yet it sits higher on my watch list than the Ancient Magus’ Bride and is one I’ve talked about a lot. The reason for that is I went in expecting nothing and got something wholly enjoyable. Fan-girl me went crazy for it and episode 4 which tied events of the first arc together beautifully really cemented this as one of my favourite shows of the season. But favourite of the season doesn’t mean I am blind to its flaws and while I will still most definitely recommend this anime as being worth checking out, to say it is one of the great anime of the year would probably be a lie.
Yet it isn’t the somewhat questionable visuals, the slight repetitiveness to the sound-track (awesome music, but repetitive), or even the heavy subject matter of hitmen and assassins being given a light comedic treatment that really stops this show from tipping into the realm of great. Realistically, it is the lack of tension and sense of danger this show has inflicted upon itself.
I know, a show about hitmen and assassins lacks tension or danger? How did that happen?
Well, the anime never, and I do mean never, actually allows the main characters to actually be seriously injured, maimed or killed. No matter what happens to them or whether they are a more peripheral main character, or even if they deserve it. No, our happy hitmen will be back playing baseball in an episode or two even after being stabbed in the gut, so don’t stress or worry. Seriously. About anyone. Everyone will be fine. At least everyone you care about because the villains are totally forgettable and throw-away and treated as such (I’m hoping for a final episode blood bath but I doubt I’ll get it).
It makes for a fun viewing experience, provided the subject matter doesn’t rub you the wrong way, but it doesn’t make for particularly deep or something that is going to have a long lasting impact.
Where to now?
The thing is, not every anime has to be great. While the great ones will awe you, blow you away, and eventually sit upon your shelf in DVD form and probably in other merchandise as well, sometimes it is enough that you have fun with what you are watching. The Near Great are the anime that keep me entertained and give me something positive to say each week. They are the anime I’ll chat about with friends and probably remember for a couple of seasons after they are done. They are anime I might even get the DVD of, once it comes down in price. The Near Great are what keep me watching anime season after season as there are many of these and they come in many forms.
So I’ll ask you now, what are the Near Great anime you’ve been watching recently?
Thanks for reading.
If you enjoyed this post and would like to see more great content on this blog, consider becoming a patron for as little as $1 a month.
Another way you can support the content here is by buying a copy of ‘Thoughts on Anime 2017‘ as an ebook. It contains a selection of reviews, features and top 5 lists from 2017 and while the content is available free on the site, this is a great way to give a one off show of support for the blog. It is available for $3.99.
Finally, you can use the affiliate link to shop at Play-Asia.com if you are interested in anime, soundtracks, figures or games. Should you use the link and make a purchase, I will receive a small percentage of the purchase price.
15 thoughts on “Friday’s Feature: What Makes Something ‘Near Great’”
“…(N)o matter how much I wished it would is how the support cast are ultimately dealt with. That is to say, how they are not dealt with.” Boom! One of the tasks of the end of a narrative is to tie up the loose ends. End doesn’t do it? Bad end. (I want to see this anyway, though, for the visual elements. The episode I saw looked gorgeous.)
For Magnus Bride something always felt just off… Just out of reach. I liked a lot of things about it, but it felt kind of ho hum. I’m not sure what yet, but once my brain figures it out I’ll probably write about it and part of what you said about the side characters made me go , “yeah that is part of what is missing” I don’t know what I wanted from that anime yet, I think I was just expecting… more… talk about vague huh? Ha
It is hard to pin down. There are pacing issues and character issues but both can be overlooked if you are get caught up in the main storyline and the pretty visuals. It was a great show to watch but something was just missing.
Great Post – I find a lot of shows are *almost* there. For me the latest one was Alice and Zoroku.
See, Alice and Zoroku was really interesting for the first four or so episodes. Then they kind of resolved their main story line and I lost interest. I never ended up finishing the series so maybe they got back to something I would have liked but I just didn’t have any reason to keep watching.
oh I understand where you’re coming from.
Well written post!
A near great for me would have to currently be Darling In The FranXX eh. Something about it makes me want to hail both Trigger and A1 as savior of caterers but then there are also some irky things that really bug me thus not willing to call it a definite great.
Totally in agreement there. To be fair, FranXX still has a second cour in store, so hopefully what comes next is enough to push the greatness boundaries. As for a show that managed to do this, I thought that A Place Further Than the Universe was a truly great anime. Love this idea and post, Karandi—either I have terrible taste or am weak to good sales, because I’ve accumulated quite a library of titles on my shelves!
Well, not everything we buy has to be the be all and end all either. Sometimes we want to consume popcorn rather than a well made dish. And popcorn can be really good if enough of the right seasonings are added in the right amounts.
Okay, I also sometimes have terrible taste. It is why I watch anime like King’s Game and enjoy it without any irony or sarcasm. I just had fun watching it.
Nice. I’m enjoying Darling in the Franxx, though there are quite a few points about it that bother me, such as not addressing its own world-building and its on going focus on the teen drama rather than on a greater narrative. I’m really hoping it does something with those elements in its second half, because if it does this will definitely become a near great for me even with some of its ongoing issues.
Why wasn’t it great for you?
It was just relaxing