Am I Being Too Judgemental Or Is My Hero Academia Season Four Just Not Good?

The answer here is that there’s probably a bit of both going on. I am being incredibly judgemental of My Hero Academia Season Four and that’s because it gave us two phenomenal seasons (season one and season two) and a third season that had an emotional peak that deserves to be remembered and season four just hasn’t stood up to the predecessors. However, given the high quality of some of those early seasons, is season four actually a pretty alright show that is just being judged harshly? Given I’m still watching Darwin’s Game, would I argue that My Hero Academia Season Four is actually worse? I decided to step back a bit and take a more objective look at the situation and why I’m finding season four so hard to feel interested in.

MHA S4 Bakago and Todoroki

Note: I will only be discussing anime in this article. I have not and probably won’t be reading any of the manga for these anime.

The Problem With Long Running Shounen

I’ve previously made it clear that the only long running shounen I’ve ever really gotten into was Bleach. I love Bleach. Partly that was because it was one of the earlier anime I watched as an adult and the thrill of being able to find the next part of an episode on YouTube with English subs that made sense was always pretty great. I also started watching it once it was well on its way so was able to binge most of the earlier seasons though did have to skip parts of some episodes just to not being able to find them. The whole ten minute maximum video length on YouTube at the time was not particularly friendly to anime episodes that were 23 – 24 minutes in length and so various people cut the episodes at various points and fan subbed them in a variety of languages.

Bleach also exemplifies a lot of the problems with long running shounen. The first three seasons are fantastic and have a wonderful character arc for the protagonist as he goes from ‘average guy who can see ghosts’ to the guy who fights his way through Soul Society to save the shinigami who gave him her power from being executed. It’s nicely done, though even those three seasons have an excess of characters, long running fights, and padding in the form of cuts to Ichigo’s sisters and other side characters that break up the flow of the main narrative.

From the end of season three on, the filler becomes the main story at times meaning there are entire seasons that can be skipped because they actually add nothing to the overall narrative and the fights become more overblown and prolonged, the character count keeps escalating, and ultimately you aren’t really sure why any of the characters have any stake in the matter other than bad things happen and good guys get to work beating the villain who caused them.

Keep in mind, I really like Bleach. I own the box sets of the DVD’s and regularly binge whole seasons of the show over a weekend just to relax. That doesn’t mean I’m blind to its flaws, just that for me it was the first of its ‘type’ that I watched and so it holds a special place for me.

The other big shounen titles have largely been misses for me. I never finished season one of Naruto. One Piece barely got a few episodes before I just kind of shrugged. I have watched segments of Dragon Ball but I’ve never been a fan. It’s watchable and if someone else wants to watch it I’ll join in. Somewhat ‘shorter’ stories like Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and Soul Eater fare a great deal better as they tend to demonstrate the characteristics of that first arc of Bleach. They tell a story, bring their characters to a nice resting point and then let things come to a close. We know there’s more to their stories but they don’t just stretch on and on adding further complication upon complication just to try to engage an increasingly jaded audience.

Hunter x Hunter is perhaps the one other long running shounen series that I’ve made significant headway through. After repeated recommendations I started watching it and for a time was reviewing episodes two at a time when I found the time, but it’s now been twelve months since I watched my last episode of it (that sounded almost like it belonged in an AA meeting). I haven’t finished it, though I’m close-ish. I actually enjoyed various bits of the story, but again, it started to feel like it had said everything it had to say and now we were just going through the motions.

So let’s bring this back to My Hero Academia.

Advertisements

My Hero Academia’s Diminishing Returns

Back when season one of My Hero Academia was airing, I originally didn’t start watching with everyone else at episode one. It was another shounen title and I was already aware they weren’t my favourite kind of show. Worse, it focused on super heroes and with the plethora of Hollywood movies even back then coming out on the topic (not to mention the various TV series) I was just kind of over it. The rave reviews of those first few episodes though made me want to give it a try at around the episode five mark and so I binged all the available episodes and was hooked.

What worked in My Hero Academia was that it was a beautifully animated show with a central character who exemplified the underdog trope while still holding onto that can-do shounen spirit and, as the story progressed, it seemed to have a lot to say about how we define and view heroic acts and those who commit them. Outside of the story being very generic in that we have a bunch of would-be super-heroes attending a training school and the main character starting powerless but telling us he’s going to become the strongest, there was almost nothing to complain about in that first season. The pace didn’t go too fast but nor did it dwell on things too long. It all just flowed in a nice looking, easily digestible package. However, it was the tone and feel of the anime that made it stand out. From the beginning, I’ve always loved My Hero Academia’s energy.

With season two dipping into a sports tournament arc, my heart initially sank. Foolish really given that group of episodes ended up being amongst the strongest that My Hero Academia would deliver over all four of the seasons that have currently aired. Character growth was logical and well delivered during this sequence and so many of the characters we’d grown attached to in the first season had a moment to shine. Also, All Might and Midoriya’s relationship also further developed as Midoriya moved less from being a fanboy to actually being a protege. They took the opportunity to identify again some of the problems with both the school and the society and then they built on that with the arrival of the best antagonist the series had ever produced (and that remains true even now) with Stain making the scene with his interesting philosophy on the heroes of society.

Unfortunately, season three ended up being a mixed bag of ideas as the League of Villains rose up and the various characters continued their various journeys to get stronger and get their provisional hero’s licence. The mid-season peak, where All Might gave his everything in one final fight, was perhaps the best moment My Hero Academia has ever produced, but it was surrounded by a season that couldn’t meet the standards of what had come before it.

And now we have season four. A season that manga readers kept insisting was going to get better, that we’d get to the awesome, it was just around the corner. Now that the whole fight with Chisaki has fairly generically drawn to a close without really raising an emotional response the chatter has switched to saying that what is coming next in the story will be amazing. Yet, My Hero Academia, as it stands, is perhaps at its lowest point in terms of being entertaining, well animated or well paced.

Advertisements

You Can’t Expect Gold Every Time

Taking a step back, My Hero Academia season four isn’t actually bad. It’s just in that weird mid-phase that a lot of long running shows go through. That peak with All Might passing the torch to Midoriya was right up there with Ichigo finally rescuing Rukia, and it is taking the show some time to set up the next big stage. When I’m not annoyed at the anime for feeling dull, I can see that The League of Villains is continuing to work away at things, that the society is changing in how it views heroes and the occupation of being a hero, and how Midoriya is trying to grow strategically instead of just frantically running to catch up. All of these developments (and dozens of others) continue throughout season four and very likely will lead to something amazing further down the track.

But right now, having watched 17 episodes of reasonably unimpressive fight sequences and character moments that don’t really go anywhere just yet, I’m feeling fatigued. A binge watch of this story would definitely have been better as it wouldn’t have prolonged this phase of the story over months of viewing but rather have been watched and done. However even then, the fight between Midoriya and Chisaki didn’t have the emotional stakes of any of the previous fights so can’t be the stand out moment that previous fights have produced and that leaves season four so far without any real climatic moment for the audience to remember and just think: “Awesome!”

When we get more critical and start thinking about the visuals of season four and the lack of screen time for so many fan favourite characters, the cracks in this franchise become more pronounced. Again, this isn’t a My Hero Academia exclusive problem. Long running shounen stories crowd in characters but they can’t all be involved in every conflict so there are large spaces of time where they get sidelined. It just feels here like that was to the detriment of the tone of the story. That energy I mentioned before.

I could also mention something about the treatment of female heroes but to be honest that deserves a whole post all on its own and I’m definitely going to get to it at some point.

Curious though as to whether it was just me being contrary or whether my feeling that My Hero Academia had already peaked and the latest offering was somewhat sub-par I naturally turned to Twitter (you know because Twitter gives you great insight into things without any knee-jerk reactions). Over two days 147 people votes in the poll and while ‘Still Fun’ won out, the vote was a lot closer than I’d initially expected. Ultimately only 54% of respondents thought it was awesome or still fun while the remaining 46% said it was only watchable or they were losing/had lost interest.

Imagine if I’d asked that same question about season 2 or 3. I’m thinking we’d have had at least 75% of respondents being awesome or still fun and far less in the lost interest category.

So is this just a lull or has My Hero Academia had its day?

Honestly, I feel like while the story still has a ways to go, my interest in it has gone. All Might passing the torch is that significant plot moment that allows the story to rest and I would have been satisfied with that as an ending. In fact, let’s change it up a bit. Let’s have All Might point saying its your turn but let’s leave Midoriya in the scene. All Might publicly passing the torch to the still green but hard working Midoriya. While he’ll need protection and mentoring from other heroes for a time, he can continue to grow into his power and eventually take the place of All might. The end.

That there are heaps of other characters still unresolved and that there are plenty of complications that can come up and be explored is not disputed. However, if the story isn’t going to be fun while exploring them, wouldn’t it be better to let it all draw to a close and end on a high note?

But I’m aware I am biased. I felt Buffy should have ended at season three and then again at season five. That is clung on to season 7 always kind of made me roll my eyes. So many TV shows just keep stretching their ideas and adding complications to the detriment of the overall narrative but for the sake of getting another season (and I am assuming more money). While some fans may be delighted by more of the characters, for me, if there’s nothing more to say, no interesting point to add, or if what they are doing is undermining what I enjoyed in the first place, I just don’t see the point.

So am I being judgemental or is season four of My Hero Academia just not good? The answer is definitely both. There are problems in season 4 of My Hero Academia. It is in an awkward transition phase and there’s been a lot of down time and less than stellar moments. Can it improve? Sure. Will I wait for season five to do that? Possibly not. Am I being judgemental? Absolutely. And it is a judgement I’ve delivered on many a story that I felt stayed past its welcome.

However, I’d love to know your take so share your thoughts below and let’s discuss the latest My Hero Academia (anime only – no manga spoilers).


Karandi - Avatar
Karandi James



Thanks for reading
and supporting
100 Word Anime.

Shop Play Asia

23 thoughts on “Am I Being Too Judgemental Or Is My Hero Academia Season Four Just Not Good?

  1. I must admit, I am not watching season 4. I was extremely late to the party with MHA, and learned that it is absolutely best binged so am going to wait until the season finale before catching up. It’s very sad to read, though.

    I’m in a similar boat. I have no real ties to the shounen demographic works (even outside of the classic fighty stuff). None of them interest me. MHA mildly interested me as a Hero School, but my ‘in’ was seeing the (first) movie with friends and loving it so much that I sat and watched the entire show – my pressing uni work be damned!

    There’s something to be said about female characters, who I would wager are some of the most thematically important pieces in the MHA puzzle while also being the continually most neglected, and it certainly sounds like that narrative is worsening. However, if the show really is a slog, I’m concerned about the viewing I’ll give in… 3-4 weeks? Hopefully it will be positive, because I’ve just seen the 2nd movie and fell quickly in love (review TBA, but I expect the score to be a 9.5/10 or higher). They’ve still got the energy there, at least!

    And, from what I’ve heard from the Weirdly Loud Manga Fans, I am going to adore a certain arc of season 4 because Jirou gets an episode.

  2. I feel the same way. S1 and S2 were absolutely fantastic, s3 wasn’t bad at all but s4 has been really disappointing.

    For me, it was confrontation/battle episodes with Chiaki and his guys. Battles being stretched over multiple episodes in shounen is nothing new, but in this season it didn’t really live up to the overall expectations/ deliver well. I didn’t find all the flashbacks particularly interesting or all that relevant in that particular moment, not to mention incredibly anticlimatic. It’s the middle of a heated battle and you want to know what’s going to happen and then it suddenly cuts to Kirishima in middle-school??? I mean maybe if it was the Final battle of the arc and the main character was about to loose and there was some dramatic music…

    Basically, I ended up pausing this show for a few weeks so I could binge them, which I def feel is a way to not loose interest so quickly, but I’m so glad that part is over. The recent episodes with the kids, Todoroki and Bakugo were refreshing and so much enjoyable than almost the rest of the whole season for me. I can say for sure I’ll at least try s5 if it ever happens, but I’ll lower my expectations a bit more.

  3. “the lack of screen time for so many fan favourite characters”

    Academia’s strong side characters are as much a liability as they are a strength. It hasn’t quite reached Raildex’s state of having too many to actually keep track of… But it has reached the point where they’re kinda bogging down the main story.

    Kirishima’s arc this season is kinda a case in point… A strong story, well executed, but taking too much time away from the main narrative. This just piles on top of Academia’s increasing problem of compact execution.

    1. Kirishima did have a great moment and I really loved that a character who had consistently been in the story got to have a moment, but you are right in that it felt like a distraction from the main story. It ends up leaving you feeling very mixed about the show. Yes, I enjoyed seeing Kirishima come into his own and feel like he could be a hero but I also just felt like removing that moment wouldn’t impact on the main storyline even a little bit from the arc and that without Kirishima’s and Sun Eater’s fights possibly the overall pacing of that final conflict could have been better (that and remove all the irrelevant flashbacks from characters that didn’t matter).

  4. I recently watched 4 episodes of BnHA in a row without much of a pause in the middle so I’d have to agree it’s better binged. The only big issue I had with those 4 was one episode where the introductory minutes were copied from the previous episode for padding purposes, an issue I’ve had with long-running shonen since Detective Conan (which probably has one of the worst cases of that, due to the structure of the mystery genre + sheer length of the series).

    I agree with Mari certain characters were done pretty well, such as Kirishima, Mirio and Tamaki’s spotlights, and the stakes are the highest ever. However, I do believe someone (it might have been you, Karandi, or Kapodaco in a collab post) mentioned because we haven’t had long with some characters – the specific one cited was Nighteye – we don’t care about them as much (and for Kirishima, who’s been around since the beginning – albeit with a different hair colour from what we’ll eventually know him by – he’s quite the vanilla character, which is something that gets challenged in this arc). I’d argue because of this, there’s an undercurrent of “I don’t care” to the arc. That’s why I can see both sides have a point.

  5. I can definitely understand your frustration with this season but to be honest, I love it. Maybe not as much as Season 2 with the amazing Sports Festival and Stain Arcs, but I think that the Shie Hassaiki Arc had a lot of great stuff that’s gone underappreciated in the community. Here’s my two cents on it:

    * Chisaki is a hella underrated villain. He believes that Quirks are a plague on society, and he kind of has a point. Quirks led to villains that cause untold destruction, and an unequal balance of power where those with stronger quirks are seen as superior. He reminds me a lot of Stain in the sense that he wanted to hold a lens to the hypocrisy of hero society, while being very hypocritical himself.
    * I actually really liked the side characters! Kirishima really came into his own, Suneater has a really unique and fun Quirk, and Mirio is the kind of hero that Deku aspires to be. Maybe some of their backstories were a bit overlong, but I loved all their big moments and I’m genuinely sad that we probably won’t see as much of Mirio going forward.
    * Genuine stakes and consequences. This arc has been the darkest My Hero has ever been, and even though the heroes win, it’s a pyrrhic victory at best. Mirio lost his Quirk, Nighteye is dead, Eri is in the hospital and clearly has some mental scars from the whole affair, and even Deku is doubting his ability to become a hero now. Horikoshi took a big risk to introduce such a dark, claustrophobic and sad arc in a Shonen Jump manga, but I think it has paid off wonderfully and I can’t wait to see what happens going forward.
    * The fight between Deku and Chisaki was In. Credible. The stakes are personal and real. Overhaul is an awesome Quirk. One for All at 100% was Deku’s Super Saiyan moment. The vocal rendition of You Say Run was beautiful and powerful all at the same time. And just seeing Deku give so much of himself, sacrificing so much to save a little girl who he barely even knows from a lifetime of torment and abuse… shit, I cried. I’d say it’s better than the fight with Stain and is almost up there with the fight with All For One for my favorite moment in the entire series.

    Well, that took way longer than I had planned but you get the idea. Season 4 is not perfect (I agree with you on some of the pacing issues and lack of female representation – seriously, where was Tsuyu this entire arc?!) but I don’t think it deserves the backlash it’s gotten in the fandom. I definitely respect your opinions, and I get that maybe a dramatic slow burn type story is not what everyone’s looking for in My Hero Academia, but ehh. I guess I’m pure shonen trash through and through. 😉

    1. The idea of Chisaki as a villain could have been good but I definitely felt the anime never really set him up for the audience to get a good read on him.

  6. Season 4 is not very good. I still watch the show but more out of a sense of obligation since I had already committed so far. I know in the past I have been a big fanboy, but even so I know that this season hasn’t been very compelling. I personally liked the Overhaul arc, but I can certainly understand why that may not be as exciting to every fan.

  7. Well, the Overhaul Arc isn’t exactly the best arc of the series so I get how your interest is waning. This current arc is a lot more mellow, personal, and deals with more school stuff so if that’s your thing you’ll like it more.

  8. I have some idological differences with MHA, so I actually started losing interest fairly early on, and I gave up on liking the story after the Stain arc (which was season 3), so I crawled through season three, said “good riddance” to the symbol peace, and successfully resolved not to watch season 4 (I should have quit after season 3). It’s not that I think MHA is bad, but I’ve never found it particular special to begin with. As a result, diminishing returns set in earlier for me than for you.

    I also don’t have the stamina for shounen fighters. It’s the one genre I tend to drop even if I actually like it (examples are Twin Star Excorcists or World Trigger). It’s the expectations that the shows just won’t end. My favourites are Soul Eater, Kekkaishi, and Mushibugyou. Soul Eater is the only one I hear people talk about.

  9. Season four has been a bit of a drag if I’m honest. Overhaul was a great character and I definitely enjoyed that arc more than whatever has been happening in recent episodes. That being said, I have to agree with Lynn. The flashbacks really dealt a blow to the Overhaul arc. It made it less enjoyable and to be honest, I kind of miss the action and tension that we saw in previous seasons.

  10. I was hyped up for this season because I’ve read the Overhaul arc in the manga, but I feel like they got the pacing and focus all wrong in the anime, giving too much time to some things and not enough to others. The flashbacks were too intrusive and never seemed to appear at the right time, constantly interrupting the action.

    It’s definitely lacked some of the wow factor that made the first two seasons so enjoyable.

    1. From comments online, people were really hyping up Overhaul but the arc itself just never felt like it got going and the new characters never got enough focus for even their names to stick and I kept having to look them up to write episode reviews. It just felt very ‘meh’.

      1. Yes. For me it’s not the school setting per se, it’s that in school there is constant progress toward a goal of graduation, and it seems like these kids will be here forever. I mean, even the kids in Luck Star finally graduated 🙂

        1. They’ve definitely taken their time getting through even a single year of school. Then again, they’d make their own title redundant if the kids hurtled toward graduation.

I'd love to know what you think.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.