Captain Earth Series Review: Earth is Doomed and As Usual Only a Group of Teens (And Robots) Can Save Us

This is part of a series of re-posts of older reviews on 100 Word Anime. The original review came out in July 2016 and can be found here.

Another post that originally I did in a plus/minus format and I’m going to try and untangle that a bit. This is an interesting series in that it is not exactly one I like but I find myself rewatching it on the odd occasion for whatever reason. As a result, I’m never really sure where I stand on it and so reviewing it kind of helps to sort out some of the clutter with this one. So without any further rambling, let’s get on with the review, and just a note there are some plot spoilers ahead.

Review:

There’s something about mecha anime that for whatever reason make me super critical before I start even watching them. It isn’t as though I dislike the genre given there are plenty of mecha anime I’ve enjoyed. I think the real issue is that the genre is a little hit and miss for me and as a general rule I go in expecting not to end up enjoying the show so the ones that work end up pleasantly enjoyable. Still, Captain Earth balances perilously in that inbetween area where I find myself enjoying it enough even as I laugh at the once again ineffectual adults who ultimately shove the entire fate of the earth onto some emotionally traumatised kids (admittedly, only two of the kids are human if that makes the concept any better).

Captain Earth at its core accepts what it is and what it is presenting. The planetary gears who act as the face of the villains for the majority of the series (before the real bad guys step forward – where have I seen that before) are as over the top ridiculous as you would expect and their motives more or less amount to being kids fighting over the largest scoop of ice-cream. About as effective too, because while they are squabbling the ice-cream probably melted and no one ended up with anything. There’s technobabble, there are the bureaucrats that get in the way, and then there are the troubled teens that all just want to help and be free and maybe pair up and live happily ever after.

This anime embraces that and makes it work. So while there is certainly plenty to mock if you are in the mood to mock, if what you want is another one of ‘those’ kinds of stories, you could do far worse than Captain Earth.

captain-earth

One of the best things about the anime are the way the characters are presented. Admittedly, all of the characters are barely fleshed out archetypes and copies of characters who have appeared in other mecha anime or the like and taken individually they don’t amount to much. However, when you step back and look at the whole cast as an ensemble and just the small touches given to them you start to notice how much thought was put into balancing the archetypes and roles. There’s no excess and some of the details are really fantastic. For instance, in the feature picture, the two ‘human’ characters in the group (Daichi and Akari) don’t zip their uniforms all the way whereas the two ‘non-human’ characters wear them completely zipped. It’s those little touches that show the individual attitudes and natures of the characters that are fun to spot throughout the series and they are consistent and actually meaningful.

captainearth4-1

Though while I’m giving the characters props, I’m going to give the planetary gears the rant they deserve. Our villains are the most cliché driven and useless creatures in creation. Their motivations are actually endlessly explained. Why are they attacking the earth? Because humans are weak and insignificant and we can devour their libido. They tell us this over and over again. Whether it is the humans discussing the threat or the villains discussing their plans. Other than that, they just seem like highly sexually charged teenagers playing with toys and their planning sucks. Let’s try repeating the same sequence of events again. Oh, that didn’t work. Maybe if I try the exact same thing? How about you try it now?

Finding out that the planetary gears were also being manipulated from above was not a surprise. Given their singular lack of a master plan other than eat everything and the fact that most of their advice came from an outside source, the betrayal is pretty inevitable and by that stage you more or less have written off these guys as pathetic.

On the most recent rewatch, I started to like some of the planetary gears a little bit more as some of their interactions weren’t as over the top as I remembered, but they are still terrible villains and they really do let down what is an otherwise fairly competent cast and realistically, a lot of my rant should be saved for Salty Dog.

saltydogcoffeecup1

These guys are the most nonsensical element of the whole show. It is like the writers knew they didn’t have enough conflict or drama with the planetary gears (given that they were useless and they needed recharging after every encounter so couldn’t attack next episode) so they threw in some of the most repugnant human beings they could find and gave them a position of authority. Delete all Salty Dog characters, cut down the number of episodes, and the anime still works and is probably the better for it. And realistically, this is probably the sticking point. Everything else in this anime is fine or actually quite good, but Salty Dog are neither interesting enough as villains or menacing enough to actually serve any purpose other than filling screen time.

captain-earth-02-10bit-720p-final_001_27371

Moving away from the characters, this anime is pretty. And while prettiness isn’t reason enough to watch, it is enough to hold your interest in the down times between attacks and the like in this series. Some of the sequences on the space station are truly gorgeous and that’s probably a good thing given little else happens on the space station (a few major plot points aside). The animation is competent and each setting has its own unique kind of feel. They certainly go out of their way to romanticise the island setting and even the trip into space has a distinct look and feel about it.

horriblesubs-captain-earth-20-720p-mkv_snapshot_21-36_2014-08-21_06-49-46

And of course, because we’re dealing with teenagers we’re going to go for a romance. It doesn’t matter that the world might end as long as we find out who ends up with who (okay, that’s a little depressing so we’ll move on from that thought). I’ll admit Daichi and Hana are adorable together but it is nice to see Akari and Teppei really grow as characters and help each other overcome their personal hang-ups. A lot of shows would have just kind of thrown these two together or left them as the friends of the actual couple we were supposed to be interested in, but these two really get the chance to shine throughout the mid-way parts of the anime. They get a little sidelined at the end, but they aren’t the protagonists so it kind of had to happen. Still, Akari’s magical girl act and Teppei’s slow growth to becoming more human, is one of the real strengths of this anime.

2s6x2zd

However, two years ago when I wrote my first review, the biggest minus of all was the failure of the plot and I have to admit, watching Captain Earth again for this review just reminded me of how big of a plot failure there is. Wow, I gave Darling in the Franxx some smack talk and yet this anime probably does just as much wrong from a plot point of view and yet I remember it affectionately. Amazing what seeing something when you are younger and more impressionable will do for your view on it.

After a barrage of half-hints and the like during the first few episodes the story then eschews all sense of mystery and just kind of hits you with enough made-up jargon to drown you in it. Following that, we settle into a rinse and repeat battle of attrition with the planetary gears. During this, a betrayal occurs (and I’ll leave that one a mystery) that leaves a new villain to move behind the scenes to set up a final confrontation that still doesn’t seem to have all that much in the way of purpose, and to distract us from this we have the Salty Dog group hindering our heroes for no apparent purpose other than ‘because’. Finally, we all get in a space ship and fly to Uranus for a smack down that happens but doesn’t and then some of us race back to earth where an even more confused smack down occurs and then somehow we all end up okay. Right.

So nothing wrong with that convoluted mess of a plot.

If you don’t think about the details it is straight forward. Kid admires father. Becomes hero in his own right. Get’s the girl. Unfortunately the details plastered on that are persistent and very hard to overlook and why should we even try. There’s also enough jargon and babble thrown at you that you keep feeling like perhaps there should be a decent plot under all of that and yet really it is the kid becomes the hero, saves the world and gets the girl plot made convoluted because its fun to try to be pretzel?

captain-earth-cover

This all brings me back to my original point. This is not a particularly good anime. The story does not hold up when judged objectively on its own merits. That was true when I first saw it, it was true after watching it again, it is true two years later when I’ve revisited it.

And yet, I like this anime.

I genuinely enjoy it for what it is and I enjoy the cast enough that even when they are taking the absurd far too seriously I can just kind of go with it. The kids get into dangerous situations and at times sustain injuries, but it isn’t angsty for the sake of it and even though these kids all have their own traumas they are genuinely fairly happy teens (all things considered). It makes a refreshing change and they bring a bit of warmth and charm to a concept that isn’t new in any way.

Sure, this won’t work for everyone but there is fun to be found in Captain Earth.

If you’ve ever had the chance to see it, I’d love to know your thoughts.


Thanks for reading.

Karandi James

avatar

Consider supporting the blog by:

Patreon2

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Or use one of my affiliate product links:


CAPTAIN EARTH: COLLECTION 1

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Captain Earth Series Review: Earth is Doomed and As Usual Only a Group of Teens (And Robots) Can Save Us

  1. I have been looking for an anime for next month’s the Best/Worst anime you might never have heard of post, and this one is on my list for that. Having read this post, and seeing that I haven’t really been covering much Mecha Anime on my blog, might mean that I am going to feature it. Because it actually sounds pretty interesting despite the fact that the story doesn’t really hold up too well 😊😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It’s a fun watch for what it is. You could definitely get super critical about it, or you can just kind of enjoy it. For whatever reason I end up enjoying it enough despite criticising certain elements of it that every so often I feel the need to watch it again.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I haven’t yet watched the series so I am not reading the entire post but when I saw my watch list, it is there and I totally forgot about it…. I haven’t been watching much since a week and a half (time issues). But now it picked my interest so I am going to watch it….
    Romance doesn’t exactly end the way we hope in a lot of mech anime so I am kind of avoiding it I guess but now I think I will give it a shot….

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I totally agree with you here. Captain Earth is a bit of a favorite of mine, despite all the flaws that it has. It takes a pretty boring and overused story and tells it masterfully, with a great main cast and incredible visuals. It’s fun without being absurd, and really plays to the strengths of what makes Mecha anime so awesome. (not to mention a bangin’ soundtrack.)

    I also get rather annoyed at Salty Dog and agree the show would be better off without them, but I don’t mind the planetary gears as villains. While they’re not anything mindblowing by any means, there’s a pretty nice contrast between the Gears and their focus on libido, with the fact that their plans are honestly pretty poorly thought through, even somewhat immature at times. They’re bratty and arrogant, and driven far more by emotion and desires than by logic, making them easily manipulated despite claiming to be these “superior beings.”

    It’s a nice contrast to the members of Team Earth, who learn to deal with their emotions, growing up and maturing together. Even Teppei, originally one of the planetary gears, slowly begins to grow, becoming more and more “human” over the course of the series.

    Thanks for the great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Glad you enjoyed it. Teppei is such a great character and really does undergo a fantastic character arc throughout the series.
      Also have to agree about the soundtrack. It is pretty awesome.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s