Tales of Zestiria the X Series Review

Overview:

Alisha (a Princess) wants to end fighting. Sorey wants Seraphim and humans to be able to live together peacefully. When Sorey follows Alisha to the human city of Lady Lake he pulls a sword out of rock and becomes a Shepherd and has to try to purify malevolence (and save the world or whatever).

I did review this week to week so if you want to know individual episode thoughts click here.

Review:

For an anime based on a game I’ve never played, I was strangely hooked by this show (after we got over the 00 episode that just seemed to exist to show off special effects and to confuse people who had no clue what was going on. That said, while I’ve thoroughly enjoyed watching, looking back this show has a lot of issues as a stand alone anime.

Let’s start with the negative and then we can look at some of the good things this show offered.

01. Running a two episode advertisement in the middle of a 12 episode series (not counting 00) kind of killed any kind of pacing or momentum and also seriously hampered plot development. Also, for those of us who haven’t played the games and don’t really want to, while the two episodes were cool, all they really made me want to do was ditch the characters from the main anime and follow the ones from the prequel and call it a day. That doesn’t really add much to your story if you show us a potentially more interesting story we could have been watching.

02. Character development is lacking. Sorey is nice and idealistic. That’s about it for him. Occasionally he get’s mad or learns something about the world but that core of idealistic and nice isn’t going anywhere and except when he is in the middle of a fight he seems to just default back to happy-go-lucky. The same can be said for most of the other characters. They have a default character and then they have the occasional emotional moment before defaulting back.

03. From a plot point of view, it’s based on a game. These are the villains, these are the heroes. There are going to be a whole bunch of smaller bad guys and side quests but mostly just go beat this thing up and everything will be fine. By the way, we’ll show you stronger bad guys early on (so that you know that we’re serious about some evil stuff coming) but we won’t let them kill you until you’ve progressed so many levels. While games can be immersive and tell compelling stories, by nature they can’t really throw the main bad guy at you too early because that would be the end of the story. Not to mention, odds of a main character dying early (while not impossible) are pretty low. We also have characters appear seemingly for no reason other than they existed in the game (okay, maybe they serve a purpose later but at the moment it was more like they just dropped in to give their name and walk away).

However, if you put up with those negatives there are some real positives to the story.

01. The characters might be a little lacking in development but the combination of characters and personalities works really well and lead to some really entertaining interactions. While most of the relationships are directed toward Sorey and the way he interacts with each of the other characters is interesting, some of the more interesting relationships happen between characters around him. Rose and Alisha had some great interactions in those final episodes (admittedly it was all kind of clichΓ© but well done). And Mikleo and Edna have been amusing ever since they met. However, it is Sorey and Mikleo’s relationship and interactions that I most looked forward to seeing. This was a really great friendship and while the final episodes sort of sidelined that relationship (there were bigger things occurring) it was probably one of my favourite parts of the show.

02. Good fantasy is hard to come by and Zestiria throws magic, purification, spirits, dragons, and everything else into the mix and for the most part succeeds (I’m still questioning the English subtitles where they called a not yet formed dragon a drake but I’m pretty sure that’s a translation issue more than anything else).

03. Good drama. We have characters trying their hardest, we have awesome fight sequences, we have political intrigue. Okay, sometimes you can’t really take the conflict all that seriously but the characters do and do so consistently. It is nice to see that they aren’t taking the challenges facing them lightly or trying to be self-aware and smug about the situation which is a tone that is saturating so much of the fantasy genre these days. Characters who are just earnestly facing their own difficulties are great to watch and you just want to get behind them, even when they are a little inept at times.

I’m not going too much into the visuals. If you read my week to week you know I didn’t much like the initial presentation. While I stopped being distracted by the way the characters seemed pasted onto their backgrounds (or I stopped caring) I never felt that all of the visual elements of the show came together. Each part is really pretty but the whole just didn’t feel right.

From a music point of view I kind of felt there was a bit of overkill at times (particularly in the 2 episode advertisement). I get that in games you get different music for different scenes but some of the transitions in the show are jarring. Like the visuals though, each bit of music on its own is actually quite good.

Do I recommend watching this? If you are a fantasy fan and you are starved for a decent anime with sword fights, magic and dragons, definitely check it out. However, as it is an unfinished story and there are definitely some issues with the pacing if you aren’t that into fantasy maybe give it a skip.

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “Tales of Zestiria the X Series Review

  1. As a humongous fan of the Tales of video game franchise, this adaptation is a humongous disappointment.

    Mostly because it offers very little to outsiders and almost nothing to people who have played the game due to a lack of anything new not already in the game. It doesn’t help that they skipped a whole lot of things because a whole lot of things only really work within the context of a game (dungeons, side quests, exploring etc).

    I’m also still puzzled why they chose to adapt Zestiria of all the possible games in franchise, since Zestiria is easily one of the weakest entries in terms of story and characters. It’s a fairly standard save the world plot and while the characters are great in their own right, they’re pretty weak when stacked up against the usual Tales fare. Zestiria is definitely not an accurate representation of what makes these games so wonderful, which is a shame if the Animes goal is to attract newcomers to the video games.

    Maybe one day we’ll get that Tales of Xillia adaptation or a remake of the Symphonia adaptation (because the OVAs butchered the plot which is one of the best stories ever told).

    My salty tears aside though, I agree with pretty much everything that was said here. I don’t hate this show, but I am incredibly salty over it due to my inner, 13 year old Tales fanboy.

    Looking forward to the second cour though. Things will get more interesting plot wise if they keep following the game.

    Oh, and the obvious Berseria advertisement episodes were shameless. While I can’t wait for the game to get localised, I really don’t think it was necessary.

    Rant over. Apologies. I should really do a write up of this one.

    Good review!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. “If you are a fantasy fan and you are starved for a decent anime with sword fights, magic and dragons, definitely check it out. ”

    That’s where I am with this. I actually got really interested in this series when you were reviewing it week to week, though I haven’t played the games either. I love fantasy stories and I’ve wanted a good series that could deliver on this (I didn’t get exactly what I was looking for in Sword Art Online) so I think I will check this out eventually.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. everyone should play the games πŸ˜€

    i agree the advertisement was weird to throw into the actual run time of the show…felt like something that should have been an OVA instead.

    point 3 in the negatives is interesting. historically, ive liked the tales games because they tend to have villains that are not just pure evil. some feel like they were forced into their roles by the environment. and the main characters dont necessarily have everything right either. but zestiria’s story seems to just throw that out.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I started watching this, haven’t played the game but am an avid Tales fan, so I figured I’d give it a watch. got 4 episodes in and stopped after they said they were going to go to other characters, so I may just skip the two that aren’t having anything to do with our main cast and finish it. That being said, I love fantasy but find these characters and setting so bland and clunky. I do agree, great character interactions, but I just am so uninvested in how any of them work together or how their story will end, even though I like the overall setting and in theory I should really like this show but something just didn’t grab me enough to want to go back to it.

    That being said, never got to where Rose and Edna showed up,so I may do what I said and finish the show then go back to the 2 episode advertisement, as you call it.

    Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There’s still a question of whether they will continue this and actually finish the story or whether this is it and they’re just going to leave us with a ‘play the game’ kind of ending. I hope not.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I am always hesitant to try animes based on videogames as they never really seem to deliver… But your review sparked some interest on my part! Character development can make or break an anime but you’ve won me over with the fantasy aspect. I definitely want to check it out now πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s