18if Episodes 2 + 3: Good Witch, Bad Witch, Whichever…


Review Episode 2:

This episode is kind of an interesting follow up to episode 1. In episode 1, you didn’t know who the people were the witch was playing with or whether there were any real world consequences. Essentially she was just playing house in dream land and there wasn’t really any need on the part of the audience to get invested. This episode makes it clear that at least this witch is having a very real impact on the real world.


Note, avoid if you are squeamish about death, dismemberment or blood. As none of these put me off in the slightest, I found the story interesting as I found the show’s very heavy handed attempt at establishing moral ambiguity for the central character. It works, but we don’t know enough about him (and is he actually permanently in the dream world or not) to really care about his colourful moral choices and the way he chooses to resolve the crisis.

I liked this. It isn’t great viewing but it kind of fits for popcorn viewing. Hopefully episode 3 can be equally interesting.

Review Episode 3:

This changes things up a bit (most notably the colour scheme) as we enter the dream of a girl who becomes a witch (which seems like it should be a big deal but apparently isn’t in this case) and then Haruto gets his heart broken (though how serious he was in the first place is still undetermined).


First episode played with split screens and eye jarring colour schemes, the second episode dove us straight into a red and black toned world of gore, and the third takes us to a washed out world of a sick girl before transitioning to a more vibrant colour scheme. Can’t wait to see what comes next.


It would be lovely to know though why only girls become witches in the dream world, why Haruto is wandering around in dream land, who Lily actually is, and whether there was some overall plot here or if we really are just drifting from dream to dream so Haruto can save all the lonely girls from their nightmares.

Thanks for reading.

If you enjoyed this post and like the blog, consider becoming a patron to support further growth and future content.



Karandi James.


14 thoughts on “18if Episodes 2 + 3: Good Witch, Bad Witch, Whichever…

  1. Episode 4 definitely went back to the same tone as episode 1 but it covered a very serious topic. It is all over the place but the intrigue is what gets me. I’m sticking with it to see if we do get some kind of answer eventually.

  2. I agree, I will like to know why only the females are witches. I’m sure guys go through some stuff. And what power does he have he can go through dreams

    1. It does look pretty. I wish I thought it would actually do something with all those questions but I’m kind of getting the impression of Flip Flappers where random stuff happens and then they run out of time so big boss fight and the end.

  3. Really good to see that you’re not hating this one. 18if isn’t great by any means, but like you said – it works pretty well as a popcorn watch as it does have a certain level of intrigue to it.

    1. I’m just kind of hoping it does something with that intrigue. Fascinating premise or not, I’m going to be a little disappointed if we don’t get some kind of explanation later.

Share your thoughts.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.